MauledAgain

Why do all people 65 or older need a tax-free life? Should millionaires and billionaire who are 65 or older live tax-free? Of course not.

The meme probably was written by someone 65 or older who was struggling financially while dealing with a tax increase, or someone reacting to a friend or family member in that situation. The meme addresses the wrong concern. It’s not that the person is 65 or older. It’s that the person is struggling financially. But people 65 or older aren’t the only people struggling financially. The concern isn’t age. It’s economic status. Should a person age 58 trying to live on an income of $7,000 be treated differently than a person age 67 trying to live on an income of $7,000? No.

Putting aside the erroneous substitution of age for economic condition, the underlying question is whether anyone should live a “tax-free life.” Someone who owns nothing and has no income might, by reason of their condition, end up paying no taxes, though that is unlikely considering that a person in that situation who manages to get some cash to make a purchase will, in most instances, pay a sales tax on that purchase. But for the vast majority of individuals, a “tax-free life” is a fantasy dream. Even the oligarchs and corporations who find ways to reduce their tax burdens rarely end up paying zero taxes. They get attention for having zero federal income tax liability but are paying fuel taxes on vehicles they own, property taxes on properties they own, sales taxes on most items that they purchase, employment taxes if they have employees, and so on.

The question isn’t whether anyone is entitled to a “tax-free life” but how tax burdens should be distributed. That question involves decisions with respect to the type of tax, the rates of tax, and the scope of the tax. These are complex issues. There’s a reason Tax Policy courses aren’t simple 30-minute meetings but require, at a minimum, multiple hours each week in a semester-long or year-long course.

But one thing can be learned without sitting through a Tax Policy course. There is no rational reason that every person reaching the age of 65 should be forever thereafter free from paying taxes.